Villa Amato - Lake Toxaway

Food can “technically” be called Italian but not great, left hungry and went elsewhere. Cheese fries are salty fries with more cheap cheese sauce than fries. Should be a takeout spot.

Small eatery with average food, good service. Go for the pizza.Vegetarian options: Vegetable pizza, pasta, and salads available, with or without cheese.

Quaint atmosphere and delicious pizza! The servers were busy but helpful and attentive.

I highly recommend this place which can be easy to miss on your way to Highlands from Brevard. First I would like to say the place has a nice warm feel and you can bring your own wine is a bonus. We ordered the Lasagna and later ordered a 14 inch meat lovers pizza with garlic extra crispy. When the Lasagna came out it was hot and very delicious the tomato sauce was outstanding. When the pizza came out it was cooked perfectly with pieces of meatballs and spicy sausage ham bacon and pepperoni. It was also outstanding. I hope that you get the chance to eat some nice Italian food.Parking: Next to a Market convenience store across the street is an ice cream shop

We’ve been going there for quite sometime and putting up less than happy to see you atmosphere because the food is a consistent average. It’s not like you’re typical Italian restaurant so don’t get your hopes up.Today I call to get a take out , they tell me they’re out of pizzas. What I said it’s a pizza joint!!! I said okay I get it , I’ll call you back in 5 minutes to give you my order for something besides pizza. I call back and the phone rings and rings. I drive 30 minutes to get there and walk in and the kid at the counter says we’re not taking orders any longer tonight. I said it would be nice for you to have answered the phone and I wouldn’t have driven 30 minutes to get average food and lousy Atmosphere!!!You’re gonna need us locals when the tourists go home. Food and atmosphere better get better or we’ll be going to your competition. Pizza Hut