The Island House - Kelleys Island

On line it shows open until 4pm on sundays. got there at 1:45. a waitress cam up and said they were closing at 2pm. said we could still order. told us if we sit at the bar we could be served faster. so we sat down. a man came up and said we are closed. when i told him that the waitress said we could still order he asked what waitress? i didn 't know her name. then he said nope we are closed...everything is closed. just plain rude!

We ate here twice today. The food was excellent and the dinner creations were fantastic. Highly impressed with the food and reasonably priced dishes. Will definitely return if we are ever on the island again.

Thoroughly impressed and pleased with the food here. Likely the tastiest dinner on the island. Staff was friendly and helped with recommendations. Specials and regular menu were both delicious. I will certainly want to visit again.

This used to be my favorite place on the island because it’s the only real cocktail bar with an expansive liquor selection. Came back this summer to find that the usal, very experienced bartenders are no longer there and have been replaced by a staff who is putting like 3 oz of aperol in an aperol spritz. Very bummed as I have always looked forward to visiting every summer and now have no place on the island to get a craft cocktail. Everything else is great and the bartenders service was quick and they were very kind. Just sorta feel like you should properly train your bar staff better if you expect them to work somewhere that’s so cocktail centered. Truly just sad my favorite spot is no longer good. Bring back the old bartenders!!

Got seated and waited 10 mins before going to the bar to see if we should just order drinks from there they said a server would be there shortly. Waiting 10 more mins went to the bar again. Was told they couldn’t sever us a server would come and take our order. Waited 5 additional minutes(25mins total) Zero service. We just left. They were not busy.