Mountain Dick's Pizza - Jay

I went into this restaurant with low expectations after seeing all the negative reviews on Yelp. Given that there's no competition in the isolated area of Jay, VT, I lowered my expectations even further. However, I was pleasantly surprised—it's actually quite good, in my opinion. I ended up going back for more on consecutive nights! I have no complaints about the pizza. Don't hesitate; give it a try!

I ordered takeout for a big group and I had very low expectations because of the poor reviews but it really wasn't bad at all. I found the pizzas with toppings to be pretty tasty. The food was ready for pickup when they said it would be. The person who took my order over the phone was polite. I would say, its not amazing pizza where I'd come to Jay Peak because of the pizza but if you're at Jay Peak and you're in the mood for pizza, this is totally adequate.

Fast, decent service, and good food for kids. This is the go-to quick meal spot for families.

I was able to buy pizza by the slice and chose a regular and a pepperoni. The pizza was just okay. The only reason I'm giving it 2 stars is that it was edible.

On the plus side, the service was excellent; the staff was exceptionally kind and helpful. However, the bland food and high prices completely overshadowed the positive service, and I definitely won’t be returning. I found myself hungry late at night with only pizza available, and it was completely tasteless. How can someone mess up pizza like this? Please don’t waste your money here; it just isn’t worth it. We felt completely ripped off. The bread was tangy and chewy, resembling rubber rather than something edible. My teeth actually hurt from trying to chew my slice. I strongly advise avoiding this place and the entire resort at all costs!