Tonyd's New York Pizza - Feedback

Very good NY style pizza, but take out orders have been overly soggy in the middle

The pizza here is fantastic, and with Melany now on the team, it’s even better. I appreciate that Tony always carries a sidearm; it's quite noticeable under his...

Worst Sicilian pizza I've ever had. Even re-heated it was dense, thin and horrible with no flavor. Cheese was burnt and sauce was acid.

Try the Margherita pizza add red onions and balsamic glaze.

The food here is excellent! The wings are a nice, medium size. The fettuccini is delicious, and the salad is fresh. The kids' spaghetti is also tasty. Just make...

Fantastic pizza! I haven't tasted anything better in Jacksonville. The bruschetta is the best we've ever tried.

We don't go as much as we want but when we go the service is excellent the pizzas very very good. And the prices are reasonable

Great place and staff. Honestly I was pretty let down though . The menu sounded great and authentic but pizza and calzone was pretty bland

Pizza tastes great (even cold)! Cashier was awesome. I got my pizza to go and they were ready in 15 minutes. Only thing I was bummed about was the pizza being a...

Amazing to find true NYC Brooklyn style pizza in FL.

Wow! I hate the cookie cutter food you get from chains, so upon discovering the gem, I could not believe it took me so long to find it. It is arguably the best...

I've only been here once and I'll definitely be returning. The staff is very friendly and hands down the best pizza I've ever had!!

Great place with great pizza and classic Italian food, even better staff.

Delicious pizza, amazing entrees, great prices and a cool staff and owner. Love Tony's!!

The best pizza ever. My kids and I love eating here! Made us feel like we were back home in NY. Closest thing to NY pizza we have found

In November 2022, the Board of Management recognized this restaurant for its excellence. During my visit in September 2022, despite the busy atmosphere, the ser...

The Pizza was amazing! Best NY pizza we've had since moving 30+ years ago. I'm all about the crust and sauce. We had the Grandma's pizza. Definitely going back...

Amazing!!! Real New York pizza, and they have Sicilian. I haven't seen that outside of NY. We've been back several times since discovering this gem. Great menu....

This place was PACKED when I arrived with my family, no where to even stand. That is all I needed to know to stick around, we waited 45 minutes to dine in and t...

First time going and recommend by a friend. I have to say that was the best pizza me and my wife had in a very long time. We got the large NY special pizza and...

LITERALLY THE BEST PIZZA SPOT and the most authentic NEW YORK STYLE RESTAURANT I've ever had!! This is now my go to spot! MAN THEY KILL IT EVERYTIME!!!

--- November 2022: Excellent in every way. September 2022: It was busy, but the service and food were fantastic. Camron does an outstanding job. In July 2022,...

The food was good, and the server was excellent. However, the service at the front entrance left much to be desired. The woman behind the counter informed me th...

As a New Yorker, I have high standards when it comes to pizza and Italian cuisine, and I have to say that both are excellent here! I also appreciated seeing the...