The Pizzeria Of Islip

Food 10/10 customer service 10/10 definitely will be returning and I live 20 min away !

The spicy vodka sauce is fire… love it! Solid pizza, good heroes… I like their Bayshore location for dine in, but the Islip location is convenient.

Those bruschetta pizza slices are ridiculously tasty ?

Went here for the first time today. I ordered the chicken wrap that had chicken.cutlet, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and I think arugula. I also had a mini rice ball. The wrap was tasty but the rice ball was ok. I have had better rice balls elsewhere. Menu not extensive because I believe their specialty is pizza. They had some pies out but none of them stood out as something I would order. Staff was friendly and the place was clean.

The pizza was great and a great selection of pies. The staff was super nice!