J&r's Steakhouse - Islip

Friendly local steakhouse with decent steaks at good prices. Their meat quality are mostly on point. Where else can you get a four course tomahawk steak for less than $40? Their prime rib is also very delicious. My only gripe is that they sometimes overcook their meats so I tend to order rare instead of medium rare to compensate. They also have pretty big portions here so it's rare to finish everything.

Very affordable lunch alternative from the typical fast food take out. Chicken pot pie full of vegetables, gravy, good consistency, good flavor not over salted. Could use a touch more chicken but for 10.99 on the lunch menu it was way more then expected. Good size portion. Pot roast, tender not over cooked. The red cabbage served hot has just enough viniger to give it a zing but not overpowering. Enjoyed the meal. Salad comes with the lunch specials, very fresh, crispy variety of greens with cucumber and tomato. Variety of dressings, I had Italian vinigeret, home made not from a jar.

I took my Nephew out for lunch.. It was the perfect place for a haven't seen you in a while (10 years) meeting.. Their onion strings and calamari was great.. We both had porterhouse steaks, mine with blue cheese a side of shrimp scampi.. J R's Martinis were delightful especially the cinnamon crunch toast martini.. I saved the best for last.. Our server Alexis was awesome the host when you entered J Rs made you feel special.. Thank You..

One of the best steakhouses on Long Island that I have ever visited. The size and tenderness of the steak for the price surpasses any other steakhouse. The staff members are also very friendly. I will definitely return.

This is one of my favorite steak restaurants. The staff is friendly and the food is excellent. I specifically came for the pasta salad, which they serve while you wait for your meal. The lunch was very affordable, costing around $11 per person.