Cottage Inn Pizza

Outstanding pizza, prices are extremely worth it for the quality that comes with it. I would recommend the buffalo ranch base with bacon with garlic butter drizzle on the crust! Overall 10/10 experience would totally recommend.

Just tried the place for the first time yesterday after being told to go here from a gas station attendant who said I would not regret it. Good was great got a sub and pizza with Cajun crust, so GOOD. I will continue to cine here the food is GREAT. Tons of options for food to choose from.!

First off, Cottage Inn offers the best deals on their website compared to other pizza spots around. I took the time to compare different menus and calculate the best values, and I was pleasantly surprised. The fantastic part is that they allow you to use multiple deals in a single transaction. I got a large pepperoni pizza with breadsticks and garlic cream cheese for just $15.99, and it was amazing! I also took advantage of their deal for two large pizzas with two toppings each for $21.99. I customized both pizzas to my liking, which brought my total to $32.99 (about $16.50 per pizza), but I truly crafted some of the best pizzas I've ever had! Just look at the photos I took; they’re absolutely mouth-watering! For one pizza, I chose bacon and grilled chicken with a pesto drizzle and garlic parmesan crust. For the other, I went for a Hawaiian combo with bacon, ham, black olives, pineapple, and red onions, topped off with an everything crust and tangy gold drizzle (I did have to pay a little extra for the additional toppings since the deal was for only two). Both pizzas tasted gourmet, usually priced around $18.99, but I got them at a fraction of the cost thanks to the incredible deals! And here’s the best part: they have apple pie pizza for only $7.99! It’s literally a dessert pizza! The only other place I know that makes dessert pizzas is East of Chicago Pizza in Marysville, so discovering that Cottage Inn offers this was a delightful surprise. It’s the perfect way to end a pizza night!

The pizza is always delicious. We usually order the Cuban pizza and the regular pepperoni, and it never disappoints. I really appreciate that we can visit any day of the week and receive the same fantastic food every time! It’s amazing!

This is a fantastic spot for pizza if you're in the Polaris or Westerville area. I had their Deep Dish Pizza with my choice of toppings, and it was absolutely delicious—cheesy and topped with perfectly cooked beef. Highly recommend!