Dicarlo's Pizza Hilliard

Your pizza is kind. The crust is homemade and the cheese is always fresh. But the best part of the pizza is the cold cheese upstairs. It makes you need to eat the pizza in the car before you go home or take and bake to try to restore a similar scenario at home. This no Frills Pizza shop is a clamp to my week!

Grown up eat this pizza from Steubenville area for 40 years and so refined to see it in Central Ohio. This is pizza best! Great crust that is exactly the right thickness with crisp crunch. The sauce and peppers are great, but the best repentance of the cheese that fills it in the box makes this pizza amazing.

Dicarlos Pizza is a wonderful experience. The crust is amazing, the sauce is super, and the cold smoked provolone on this hot steaming crust is an absolute brilliant idea! Love it!

I've been going to this place for years. Always great service, Lady is so friendly. Sometimes a little busy, but I don't mind waiting. Pizza always hot and crisp! Defiantly recommend for others. My favorite pizza by far!!!

No frills pizza, crunchy but not thin, with cold mozzarella cheese sold in bags to add on top. A very unique and delicious experience. Definitely would recommend. Tucked near a gas station in Old Hilliard, this unassuming pizza parlor does an incredible job. It's menu is quite limited, just serving 4 toppings (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom and banana peppers) and pepperoni rolls (a popular side item well-known in West Virginia that is essentially a simple calzone). Be sure to order at least one bag of fresh provolone to sprinkle on top of your pizza. You can also order a cup of banana peppers as a cold topping too. Heads up that as of Nov 2020, if you order online you won't have access to any toppings except for pepperoni. Call in your order if you want sausage, mushroom or banana peppers cooked on top.