Di Maggio's Pizzeria - Hicksville

Order from here for years, always great tasting and cheap prices. Love the sesame crust!

Excellent New York style pizza with a great selection and some of the best crust I've ever had. Tastes like home. Very friendly staff and quick service too.

This used to be my go-to spot ever since two guys took over from retirement. My friends and I used to love coming here, but I lost track of it after I heard it changed ownership twice in the past six months. The quality has definitely declined with the new owners. The most recent visit had a barely-there amount of cheese on the pizza, with a thin and tough crust, and no sesame seeds. Even the special items were disappointing. As someone else mentioned, it may be time to find a new place to eat.

The best pizza in the world? I love her every week!!

Wow!! I haven't been here in years and I'll never go back! I ordered an order of Shrimp Fra Diavolo and a side of meatballs. What I received was an order of overcooked meatballs and a plate of pasta and tomato sauce. ZERO SHRIMP!!! $25 completely wasted. Biden inflation is one thing.. This was robbery! Side note :I had no idea this place was under new ownership, but seeing as how bad their service is, I don't see them lasting long.