Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer

Excellent. this place makes a great cake. they use such high-quality ingredients that they do not have to hide behind the bucks of sugar and salt. these people know what they do.

This pizza is large and in charge! Loaded with toppings and crust with the cheese baked into it. It’s amazing. Also the chicken tenders are hands down the best in the area.

Great service (owner and all of the workers are very professional and personable) and amazing food (always fresh and worth every penny)!! Best pizza place in town!!

We stopped into Tony's on the way out of Cooperstown, and bought three pizzas and a couple of salads. It is a clean but small restaurant that seemed to be pretty busy on a Sunday evening. The Pizza was good with a crust that was a little thicker than we expected. The inside out pizza was very good. The Buffalo chicken salads were very good. Service was very good, but when asked if there was a pizza that was a speciality of theirs, they didn't have any specific recommendations. It is so important to know what you do best! If you're stopping through and looking for pizza, this is a great stop. I wouldn't make it a destination solely for the pizza, but it's probably a solid 7.5 on the pizza scale.

Hot damn, it's a little pricey but honestly 200% worth it. There's actually toppings on the pizza! It's not just some little sprinkles of bacon, pepperoni, sausage, etc. It's actually worth what you pay! Great service and better food, definitely gotta go.