Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn - Hancock

Parking: The restaurant has a large, free parking lot. However, it can get crowded, so if you arrive at 6pm on a Friday, you might have to park on the street if the lot is full.

Great place to eat. Not the cheapest but you get what you pay for. Food and service was great. We went on a Tuesday night and made reservations for 6 but they would not have been needed because it wasn't crazy busy. The parking lot was full but inside didn't reflect that. I eat out maybe once a year but I will be back there a lot soonerFood: 5/5

We were initially excited to try this restaurant, but unfortunately, we will not be returning. I made a reservation on Friday for a party of 4 on Saturday. When we arrived, no one could locate our reservation among a mess of handwritten notes. Eventually, we were seated and ordered an appetizer and drinks. Despite requesting that bacon be served on the side due to dietary restrictions, our dish arrived with bacon. A replacement was brought out, but it was cold and served at the same time as our main courses. Three out of four meals were incorrect, but we were so hungry that we ate them anyway. The manager did not come by to address our concerns, and we were surprised to see that our bill did not reflect the mistake with the appetizer. When I mentioned this to our server, their response was lackluster, claiming that they had remade it. I was disappointed by the overall lack of concern for our dining experience. The server even had the audacity to wish us a better experience next time. Additionally, I previously left this feedback on their Facebook page, but they have since blocked me to remove the review. I created a Yelp account specifically to share my thoughts, and I am now leaving a review here.

I just tried their food for the first time and it was amazing. We ordered a bushel of #1 male crabs, the crab and artichoke dip, stuffed mushrooms, flounder, and shrimp and wings. Everything was delicious. These were the best crabs we have had in over 10 years and the flounder was the best cooked fish I've ever tasted. We will definitely be coming back regularly. The service was also excellent.

In my 83 years this is only restaurant I can honestly report to have had all 5 star meals, all entrees excellent, and first rate pleasant service. Most restaurants have some lapses, some lesser servings, but all we have had, alomng w/ fellow diners, has been spot on. I only wish they had modern restrooms!