Lillo's Tomato Pies - Hainesport

Luvvv the Cheesesteak. Can't wait to bring the kids for pizza!

Really delicious pizza and chicken cheesesteak! Super friendly staff as well! I’ll definitely be back again!

They have great cheesesteaks, when they dont run out. They are unable to keep up with their demand, which unfortunately makes them very hit or miss. Called to order a bunch of pizzas and I was told they don't take pre-orders. When should I order it??? Then I called another day to order and they said walk in only. So I went there and ordered and sat outside for 20 mins waiting. I think the food is very good and apparently they are doing well, I just feel their popularity takes away from the convenience of ordering out. I would definitely recommend going there if u have time. Maybe try to call ahead and figure out the protocol for the day. Do u have any cheesesteaks left? Can I order by phone or do I have to come there and sit and wait? Depends on your schedule. Update: stopped in Sat afternoon for a cheesesteak, WAY to salty. Ruined a $20 cheesesteak

Got an American with fried onions cheesesteak, the roll was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Only con was a bit too much cheese.The plain slice had the perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio with a thin crust. The crust at the end was a bit too dry and hard probably bc it was a reheated slice. Will get

Really friendly staff top notch customer service. The cheesesteak was a lil pricey(understandable) but it is worth every penny. This seems like a place worth visiting frequently.