Tony's New York Pizza - Greencastle

I am new in town and want to support the local businesses. I have been ordering pizza from Tonys on a regular basis. I was happy with their delivery service, and even if the pizza was not always completely satisfactory, I continued to order from them. Tonight, I ordered a grilled chicken salad that I picked up myself. By the time I got home, the paper bag completely soaked through and left a puddle on my car seat. From a chicken salad? I wondered. In the house I dumped the bag in the sink. From the clear plastic container, I drained another half cup of liquid: my chicken and the whole salad was soaked in water and was all soggy, completely unenjoyable. I called back, but my call was completely useless. This experience totally changed my 5 star review. I am looking for another local business to support.

Disappointed. I’ve had their wings.. much smaller and buffalo sauce doesn’t compare to the old Tony’s. Also I just ordered a penne alavodka. No prosciutto!!! It advertised with deglazed prosciutto and not One morsel!! Only onions. The sauce was like water. Could’ve been a lil thicker. Very disappointing

This place has fallen off a lot. Ordered two capicola subs with lettuce tomato and onion oil and vinegar peppers on the side. The came out no tomato very little oil and vinegar. Plus gobbs of mayo that shouldn't have been there at all. Our order of fries were good what there was of them, less than a small at mcdonalds. New owner has some major work to do

Terrible pizza place. Management clearly has no idea what they are doing. Ordered a single Caesar salad, and waited 25 minutes. Don’t waste your time, if your in a rush. No to mention the salad was soggy. The cashiers customer service was terrible, and acted as if it was the customers fault for ordering food and then being behind.

Fabulous. Always a family favorite and the food is on point.