Tony's New York Pizza - Greencastle

Had a mixed experience with Tony's. I ordered a pickup and the woman I spoke to on the phone was unfriendly and seemed to be rushing. I'm sure she...

Good food if you have a lot of time on your hands. The service is ok, but it takes too long to get your food. With more than one occasion...

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3

I'm at foodie person so my food's got to be perfect when I eat it The bread was definitely cooked to perfection on my pizza The sauce was a little watery and the cheese was not to my liking I'd rather have a mozzarella cheese on my pizza and a homemade sauce made to perfection I also had the cheese fries which were good Cook too perfection and perfect amount of cheese Service: Take out

This place used to be the best pizza when the old man was around. now very little cheese crust very hard on the floor and I h8 to say, but brother pizza has beaten her