Gerace's Pizzeria - Goshen

Amazing food. Fresh ingredients and very friendly staff. Kinda pricey. But definitely worth it when the quality is as high as it is. My family won't eat at chain pizza places anymore. You definitely get what you pay for.

Are you under new ownership? Not the pizza we are accustomed to. The crust and sauce were completely different and the cheese, which used to be our favorite part, was unremarkable. wishing you the best of luck with your new recipes… but we will not be coming back :

DO NOT order online! Ordered $95 worth of food online. The website said that ordering online was best. I didn't get a notification that our food was ready. I called and was put on hold (phone was sat down), which is not a problem because they were busy I'm sure, but I heard her take 2 orders in the time I was waiting so I figured she forgot I was there. I hung up and waited a few minutes, then called back. No answer so I just decided to go there and see if our food was ready. Apparently, it had been ready for a while because it was cold. The girl there told me that I should have called to check on it. We put it in the oven, and it just tasted nasty. Pretty much like what it was.....reheated food. Plus, I didn't get the marinara I paid for. Needless to say, that'll be our last experience there Too expensive for such poor quality and service Also , for the review about a hair in their pizza.....not 1 employee i saw had a hair net on

Pizza is not the same as it used to be. Very thin. We were pretty disappointed. To make matters worse, found a piece of black hair baked into the pizza.

Horrible, expensive pizza!! My wife and I both feel sick!! I'll never go back!! They can say all they want but our pizza was disgusting and I'd never waste my money trying it again!!