Pizza Supreme - Feedback

Friendly. We like the square discs best. Drinks are too expensive. Menu prices are fair.

Best pizza I've ever had! I used to go to the original location in Hicksville back in 1957, and I've followed them to every spot since. Whenever I'm back on Lon...

Whenever I host a party, I always choose Pizza Supreme for catering. The staff is extremely professional, and Joe consistently goes above and beyond to ensure o...

We got a supreme pizza from Pizza Supreme and it wasn't your average supreme. It was WAYY above average, with slices soo big and toppings piled high. Their wing...

Great square slices. Always fresh. Garlic knots are some of the best I have ever had. Can eat just the knots with a side of sauce as a meal. Covered in oil, gar...

You haven't truly enjoyed pizza until you've tasted the square pizza from the original creators.

Absolutely delicious! They were cooked to perfection, crispy, and served hot. This could be one of the best rice balls I've ever had.

The slice sizes are generous, which I really appreciate, and they offer a wide variety of toppings.

The best meatballs anywhere! Their distinctive square pizza is amazing, and they offer a wide range of other tasty pizza styles and baked dishes. I've been a fa...

Excellent pizza and food, always on time and hot

Joe and his team are so nice! I’ve never had a bad experience. Food is delicious and fresh. And, you MUST order a square pie my family’s all time favorite and y...

Pizza Supreme was previously located in Roosevelt Field, near the Time Out Arcade. Their square pizza was always exceptional. There's nothing quite like enjoyin...

My dad works at the restaurant, so I had the opportunity to enjoy a complimentary meal, and I have to say, the pizza is absolutely fantastic! Everything on the...

For years, Pizza Supreme has consistently offered a wonderful taste of Italy. Famous for their square pizzas, you definitely should add their garlic knots to yo...

Friendly. We like the square slices best. Drinks are way too expensive. Menu prices are fair.

Whenever my friends visit from out of town and crave New York/Long Island-style pizza, I always take them to this place, and they absolutely love it. The staff...

This establishment takes their craft seriously and they really deliver. If you're visiting from another state and in search of a true taste of New York pizza—be...

Amazing pizza! It takes over an hour to reach the place, but it's definitely worth the journey. If you're in the vicinity of Roosevelt Center Mall, make sure to...