New Jersey Pizza Co - Flagstaff

Omg! This place is 100% a gem! The quality of the food is amazing! The wings are incredible. The pizza is legit awesome! Best pizza in Flagstaff hands down and I’m super picky when it comes to wings and pizza. This place gets 5 stars for sure!

Ok so the reviews are correct about this being a slow food experience. But the staff is friendly and this is top notch food (quality ingredients, fermented crust! And a house made gf crust for our daughter! ; so bring good company, order a glass of wine, and enjoy the wait.

The best I’ve ever had.Thank you New Jersey Pizza Company!!!

Amazing food. Visiting from Phoenix for the weekend and will be returning just for this pizza! Service was excellent and everyone was so

The meats they use on the pizza are tasty but the pie does them no justice. We ordered a 12 and a 16 , both two toppings. The 16 was so greasy and limp that you could barely hold it, half of it went to waste. The 12 bottom crust wasn't as soaked, but still dripping everywhere. I'm not sure why it seemed so wet when there didn't appear to be that much cheese or sauce??We were quoted 35-40min for pickup and it ended up being an hour and 15 minutes. Prices are absurd for what you get. There's other pizza within a mile of this spot that's both better and cheaper.