Brooklyn Pizza Llc - Erie

The lady who took my order over the phone had a hard time getting what I wanted. there were 3 different medium pizzas. one- and two-to-one. after a few minutes she repeated it right. I'm coming 30 minutes later to pick them up and one of the 3 was wrong. I asked for a new pizza. sa and waited for almost 30 minutes. for my inconvenience, instead of a medium, I got a big good, thank you! I guess they threw the wrong one away. I got home and the first two pizzas were now cold, no surprise really and all 3 had really hard crusts. two were unthinkable! one of them was burned down. the taste was pretty good, but for $30, I will never be back!

Took my family on a weekend trip to Splash Lagoon. Saturday night, pizza was sounding good, so we decided to try this place. Called up for delivery, was told it would be about an hour, maybe a little longer. Ordered an 18 meat lovers, and a 14 cheesesteak pizza and a couple 2 liters. Staying at a hotel, asked if they could send plates, napkins and cups also. Was told this would be no problem. Took about an hour and a half to an hour and 40 minutes to get there, no plates, cups or napkins. The pizza itself was average. Both pizzas were pretty light on toppings, the cheesesteak had the veggies, but almost no meat. The meat lovers had it's toppings, just, by the name you expected more. Both pizza's were pretty dry, neither had any real sauce that was noticeable. The cheesesteak had a pretty wide crust around the outside, the meat lovers was a little better on that part. Honestly, just not impressed by the food. I asked the kids, and they both agreed that the fresh cooked pizza I brought home from Sam's Club a couple weeks ago was better.

I went to get a large Pepperoni Pizza with my wife. I was so hyped about it because they had recently opened again. And to my surprise coming home, it looked like a cheese pizza. The pricing was high but I figured that the pizza would be worth it, I was wrong completely. I had high expectations for them and was disappointed. If I go again, I hope that they get better, nice people but seem really cheap with giving toppings.

I wouldn’t recommend. The pizza was room temperature and somewhat like cardboard. The only employee on duty was more interested in her cell phone than serving customers. I ordered, looked at my wife to ask for her order and the woman behind the counter had already walked away back to her phone. She seemed irritated to serve us. There’s a lot of other options in the area that are happier to see customers.

We eat here often. Today by after the worst pizza I've ever had, ordered a lg margherita pizza without sun dried tomatoes and added banana peppers, instead they took off the fresh tomatoes and they were about 10 banana peppers, the driest pizza I've ever had. VERY disappointing. When I tried to order the week before was told they could fill my order, due to another larger order. Will be awhile before we go here again.