Captains Pizzeria - Elkhart

I ordered a large combination pizza, and it was excellent! The staff were very friendly, and the pickup at the drive-thru window was quick. I'll definitely be back soon. Thank you and keep up the fantastic work!

Delicious pizza and excellent service! We ordered a veggie pizza, and they actually called us to let us know they were out of spinach and wanted to check with us before finalizing the order. It was such a considerate gesture, and we truly felt cared for. The veggie pizza was fantastic, and the garlic bread was perfect. Thank you for a wonderful meal; we’ll definitely return when we’re in the area!

We discovered Captain while searching for a small business to support during these challenging times. We ordered some pizzas, and they were fantastic. Thank you for a wonderful experience— we'll definitely be back!

Never eaten here before, but it always went to Michigan. It was Date Night! We ordered the great Philly Cheese Steak pizza and while cooking we picked the brews next door in the liqueur. We have a menu to take home and it comes with a magnet on it for your refrigerator, which I really liked. When we picked up, the service was excellent! Super cool people who love pizza like us. The pizza was perfectly joined together, it was actually as nice to see as it was soooo good to eat. Best Philly Pizza I ate. I tell all my friends and Fam, and we can't wait to go back. We want to try the stuffed bread sticks next time! My only regret is that I didn't tip them higher because they really deserved it.

Really enjoyed the pizza: piping hot, SMOTHERED in cheese and very tasty. My wife's club salad was huge and everything was incredibly fresh. Most amazing? The staff! Each and every one so very friendly. I felt as if we were special houseguests!