Melissa's Pizza And Italian

I don't eat many places, but I will stop fast delivery service, quality of food and simple order at Brothers Pizzaria several times a week because of the excellent customer. I have everything from pasta to wraps to the most authentic NY pizza in Poconos! I recommend everyone in the area to give this facility an attempt and if you go through, mark it on your map!

Brothers has classic pizza in my eyes. The crust is thin, the sauce is slightly sweet and the cheese is perfection. I have only ever ordered a plain pizza and garlic knots so I can't really review anything else on the menu. I always ask for crispy and I will say the only reason they didn't get 5 stars is because I believe they have different people making the pizza and the dough isn't always as stretched out or as crispy as Id like it. However, the day I took this picture it was perfect. You also can't go wrong with their garlic knots.

The owner was right, we will be back. Finally found fresh ingredient pizza, good garlic knots, and awesome wings all in one spot.

This is a 5-star review for a Poconos restaurant. If I had tried this pizza in NJ or NY, I would rate it 4 to 4.5 stars, but in this area, it truly stands out. My girlfriend picked up some items from the dollar store in the same plaza, so I ran over to grab some slices for us. The pizza had minimal bending, with a beautifully thin crust and a perfect balance of cheese to sauce. It reminded me of the NJ and NY pizzas I grew up loving. A few weeks later, I had a simple white cake, which was also very good. While the pizza’s quality can be slightly affected by the cardboard packaging, it still holds up as a solid choice. We’ll definitely be back!

Great pizza, delicious Philly cheese steaks, and wings! The staff is consistently friendly, and the delivery drivers are always pleasant and quick. While many places claim to serve New York-style pizza, these folks are true New Yorkers from a hidden gem. I highly recommend this pizzeria!