Rolling Pin Bakery - East Setauket

I absolutely love the Rolling Pin! The cakes are consistently delicious and beautifully presented. The staff is courteous, helpful, and very accommodating. I'm so glad to have such a fantastic bakery in town!

The best cannoli I've ever tasted! Seriously, you have to treat yourself to a large one with chocolate chips. They fill it fresh on the spot, so the shell stays crispy. I don't mind spending $4 for one as long as it's this perfect!

This charming neighborhood bakery offers excellent cakes and cookies. While the selection isn't vast, everything they serve is delightful. The strawberry shortcake, in particular, is a must-try!

The cake was delicious! People we shocked that my wedding cake was funfetti ?. It was absolutely stunning as well. Really just breathtaking to look at.

Wonderful working with this bakery for our wedding cake. Prompt email repliers and made it easy for the selection-choices outlined clearly with possible add ons and what is/isn't supplied. We went with the banana custard with vanilla sponge cake to have something different- it was an absolute hit. People are still complimenting it a few days later as a highlight of the event. Not only that but the cake was beautiful, very classy and simple design just as we hoped. Thanks so much!!