Papa Johns - East Orange

Second time ordering from here,first time I ordered extra sauce and this time which is my second,the sauce was pressed in my pizza like on purpose or something?theeen I gave driver my exact balance for order and then he called me three times saying I?mmissing three dollars I guess cause three dollars was the suggested tip for order?

I had a terrible experience at this restaurant. I placed an order through the Papa Johns app at 11pm on a Monday night. The app said it would be a 30-minute wait, but I ended up waiting for over 2 hours and never received my order. The app notified me that my order was on its way and then that it had been delivered, but there was no pizza or driver in sight. I tried calling the store, but the machine said they were closed. Very poor service, and I will never be ordering from here again.

The pizza was disappointing - greasy and soggy, just not good. However, the wings were fantastic. I frequently order from this restaurant, but today's pizza was terrible.

Nice and friendly staff. Takeout Medium pizza with chicken poppers. I've forgotten how sweet Papa John's tomato base sauce is. Not my fave since I've had authentic pizza living in NYC. But fours stars for service, cleanliness, and for those who like thepizza.

I ordered 4 large pizzas from Papa John's using their app, but 3 of them were not made correctly. The restaurant promptly sent me 3 replacement pizzas while letting us keep the originals. This excellent customer service, along with the delivery guys doing a fantastic job of getting the pizzas to us on time, really impressed me. I'm not sure why this place has received negative reviews, as I would definitely order from them again.