The 5 O'clock Club - Cumberland

I really was hoping for a better experience here particularly given the positive reviews. The service was one notch above abysmal. And there were plenty of people working (so there really was no excuse for the poor service). Food was average at best but the portions were large. Prices are high. The nice atmosphere is the only high point if the meal. They do charge extra if you are paying with a credit card.

We called last minute Friday afternoon for an evening reservation. Glad we got one. First time here. Food was... Wow. Drinks and bartender were fantastic. We had an amazing beer cheese soup with mushrooms. The walleye filet was large and flavorful with no bones! Then another person in our party ordered stuffed shrimp wrapped in bacon with homemade fettuccine as a side. A huge wow for the pasta and seafood! Two of us got the east coast west coast platter. One of got it fried while the other got broiled so we could share. It was delicious. The price point for the food was perfect. One of the best supper clubs I've been to in a long time. Highly recommend and can't wait to come back!

Food was excellent as well as the drinks, sadly they lost power just as we got served and other people had to miss out on the experience we had, will be back again someday!

It 's a beautiful setting watching deer meandering through the yard with the lake in the background. We went at 7:30 (with a reservation we made at 5pm on a Wednesday evening. Food was very good and our waitress was wonderful... but you could tell the wait staff was maxed out. About 2/3 of the available tables (and the deck? were closed presumably due to lack of staff. Two of the evening 's specials were no longer available at 7:30. We had a wonderful meal, and will return.

We had reservations and when we arrived we were seated promptly. Our group opted to order the all you can eat shrimp. It was outstanding, I especially liked the broiled version. I highly recommend this restaurant and will be returning to try the other menu items in the future.