Bagels On Hudson - Croton On Hudson

I've been coming to this bagel place since I was a little girl, it's truly a neighborhood staple. The bagels are delicious, orders are taken care of relatively fast, and the staff are nice enough! I'm also shocked by all of the horrible reviews but I chalk it up to a preference of bagel texture: these bagels are on the doughier/chewier side, but I have never eaten anything from here remotely inedible or undercooked. Their egg breakfast sandwiches are delicious as well as a their lox, however the one downside to this place is that it is pretty expensive, a lox sandwich will run you around $15. It's small on the inside with a few booths, so when there's a long line it gets crowded but moves fast. I also just got half a dozen bagels to go for the first time and have zero complaints, they were cooked perfectly fine again I think the complaints are more due to texture preference based on who's eating the bagel. In the 25+ years I've been coming here the food and service has always been consistent.

The bagels are the best in the area hands down. Staff is great. Go to place for a breakfast sandwich!!

Home of the world's SMALLEST bagel! Seriously, what's with that? Tuna salad w/bacon on bagel $11. If it was a FULL SIZE bagel with way more tuna, maybe. Don't charge full size sandwich prices when you serve it on a hockey puck. For $1 more I could have gotten the same thing on a wedge down the road at the mini-deli and it would have lasted 3 lunches. Idk.....seems way overpriced to me. Not going back.

Rainbow bagels and ice cream makes for a magical experience. Yes, the bagel shop serves ice cream. Do they serve bacon ice cream??? The strawberry ice cream had whole chunks of delicious strawberries. Be prepared for a line, and be patient, it moves fast.

A regular must visit in Croton for breakfast, bagels, spreads, sandwiches and great deserts