New York Pizzeria - Feedback

Very few selections around cooperstown, but I met the jackpot who chose it tonight. we had the small pizza 20 wings special. the only strange thing.

It is obvious that they use cheap ingredients because their pizza has no taste. they're using it. dough has no taste and, her ****.

The pizza in the disc was somehow stale. tried. friendly staff. the bathroom is not used.

Keep them here whenever they visit cooperstown. was pleasantly surprised pizza slices were still only $2! even better was informed about the lunch speciality th...

Our family has made it a habit to visit a tradition really, the fly creek cider mill at least two or three times a year. we usually get pizza in oneonta, but th...

The Italian sausage pizza I had was amazing. I have at least 3 more pizza shops on the ride there and it was so crazy worth it.

When son stopped at Cooperstown Dream Park. Not being from New York, but hearing how great the pizza is, they didn't disappoint.

In town stopped to see the fame hall. This place was not disappointed. Pizza was by far one of the best I ever had! Friendly staff, too. Thank you.

Delicious! I finally understand why NY Pizza is the best pizza.

Great pizza (loved the gluten free option) and friendly staff

This is not what I would call NY Pizza. I ordered 2 slices with green peppers and onions. I have 2 smooth slices with raw peppers and onions and a few melted mo...

My mother (the 95 is)ever has 2 slices of cheese pizza and ordered 2 slices of cheese and sausage to take home, I had the pizza through the slice and the calzon...

Adult in New York City this is the best pizza I've had for years? Antipasta salad was amazing? Huge portions, great service, great prices Very recommended, I co...

Wow. I lived here about 6 years, and I know there's a lot of life here, but never was a fan. I keep trying different things and never was a fan. Then I heard th...

Here for HOF weekend and this place is awesome! Had two 18 inch pizza for a family of 7 and we still had leftovers. Definitely try the cheese sticks! Thank you...