Butterly Bakeshop - City of New York

I called in one week to get a cake made for my wife’s surprise party I was throwing for her, and I know nothing about ordering a cake! Erika took the call and was entirely helpful. She helped me to figure out what to get and my wife loved it! My wife is very fussy and she enjoyed it, so I think it’s safe to say that we will be back. Thank you Erika!

I bought a pumpkin pie from Butterly Bakeshop last year for Thanksgiving, and there was no way to describe this pie other than perfect. They have simply perfected the pumpkin pie. On Thanksgiving, our desire for that perfect, satisfying pumpkin pie is so strong, and this pie satisfied this desire to the moon and back. It was exquisitely spiced, with just the right about of kick while still being smooth. Just an extremely satisfying and delicious pumpkin pie.

The BEST cookies. Cupcakes also never disappoint, I’m sure everything I haven’t tried is delicious too.

Love the banana pudding! Def Wirth a shot. Ny mudcake was good, too.

Amazing! We ordered a small cake and some cupcakes for my sons 3rd birthday. Erika was amazing helped us pick the perfect cake and made sure everything went smoothly. All of the guests were so impressed and many asked us where we got the cakes from. The cakes were moist, not too sweet and full of flavor. We ordered the strawberry milkshake cake and the strawberry filling was fresh and bursting with real strawberries. We are so happy we found Butterly and will be using them for our party cake needs from now on. Wishing endless success to this wonderful little bakery.