Magro's Italia Pizzeria - Cincinnatus

The service was excellent—friendly and helpful. The food was incredible and absolutely delicious!

The food was great! It’s surprising that, for a pizza restaurant, they don’t offer any party packs or bundle deals for whole pizzas. However, the prices are reasonable even without any discounts. The staff was also very friendly, making it a nice spot to grab some pizza.

The portion sizes are very small. We ordered meatballs and pepperoni but received sausage instead, and there was no sauce at all! I paid $2.50 for each topping, and it looked like they used maybe a quarter cup of sausage. It's frustrating to feel overcharged like this. The quality seems to be getting worse, and it’s clear they don’t prioritize their customers. Honestly, I think this place should consider closing down.

Every time I get pizza here I'm pleased. They have a great all around pizza and awesome crust!

Ordered two sheet pizzas for an event this evening. They were ready for me when I came to pick them up. The guy on the shift was very friendly and accommodating, offering to carry the pizzas out to my vehicle for me. The pizzas were good, no short-cuts with the sauce or cheese. The pieces were cut through, which was a big help when we were serving the pizza at our event. A few times a year my organization orders sheet pizzas from Magros, as we really don 't have anything else in our town. The quality has, over the years, varied somewhat; but, we like supporting our local businesses. This time Magros was spot on.