Chilmark Tavern - Feedback

Food was fine. Restaurant is byob. I brought a 2000 leoville poyferre and asked waiter to decant it. Obviously he just poured it into decanter as sediment degra...

Not a fan way too loud and it was not even crowded. menu was dull and overpriced. Had way better meals in MV

Cute place and the food was good. Very loud during the peak times.

Amazing food and service. Top notch every time I’ve been there. Jenna runs an amazing place and between the food and the service you’re sure to Have a great exp...

Menu limited and quite costly but ingredients are fresh and preparation quite inventive . Sauces Well prepared . Lovely evening

Thanks for having vegan options available. The “Vegan” was delicious.

The food was great as always. Fish items cooked perfectly. The tavern is very loud so be ready for that.

The food is delicious! The only two negatives are: 1. the $14 uncorking fee combined with the $6 fee for an ice bucket is unreasonable, and 2. the noise level i...

I hadn’t been to Chilmark Tavern for several years. My previous meals there were good, but this time the meal was fabulous. Two of us had the scallops, and a th...

We come to Chilmark at least once each summer and have done that for years. We love it for its consistent quality and atmosphere. Seasonal ingredients, creative...

For the price, there are much better restaurants on the island. The $47. fish chips were small over cooked. As opposed to, say, Atria where they give you an ent...

Awesome service and great ambiance. The food was good not great. We got the greens salad, bread, chicken and burger. Nothing blew us away but it was all good an...

Ok let me start off by saying quite possibly the nicest staff on island, I'd never been there before... walked in without a reservation and they took me in 15 m...

Well I said I would be back and I wasn't disappointed. We ordered the mussels again and saved the sauce for our chips. The best fish chips I have ever eaten. Hu...

Stopped spontaneously on the way back from the magnificent sunset at the cliffs!! I would definitely recommend having a reservation here. Plan ahead. We waited...

It’s just incredible how in one of the toughest businesses made more difficult by seasonality and staffing challenges that this upscale but casual byob restaura...

Overpriced for mediocre food. extra fees added: BYOB charges 15$ for “wine service” and gratuity is automatically added for kitchen staff. The kitchen staff’s r...

What a way to end the day with love and kindness and great food. Perfect service and a beautiful vibe. BYOB and creative alcohol free cocktails. Chilmark’s best...

Where do I start. A relative thought this place was good for our family and friends to go to while on vacation in Martha's Vineyard June 2023 . We waited 45 min...

A pleasant surprise! We hadn't dined here before but it came recommended so made the drive from Tisbury. One could tell by the clientele that it was no secret,...

We were excited to sit outside under the lights and enjoy the atmosphere at this restaurant. Make a reservation with Resy. Everything Up-Island is BYOB, so this...

The atmosphere upon entering was nice and the seating was comfortable. The food was served promptly and timed well. Our server was not rude, but lacked friendli...

This restaurant is fantastic for casual dining, both indoors and outdoors. Although their menu may be limited, there is surely something to satisfy your taste b...

This restaurant is a great choice for those seeking a high-quality dining experience. They offer one vegan entree that is clearly labeled on the menu. On this o...