Benny's Pizzeria Incorporated

I absolutely adore this restaurant! The food is consistently fantastic, and the team that runs it is truly wonderful.

Since moving to New York, this has become my favorite pizza place. The service is excellent, and there are so many options that it can be tough to decide what to order. Everything I've tried tastes amazing!

I spent a lot of my childhood visiting this place with my mom, and I fondly remember chatting with Benny, who was such a kind person. I used to excessively salt my pizzas, but I absolutely loved it here. The pizza they serve is truly amazing. I know it's been some time since I last visited, but if you live nearby, definitely stop by!

I've lived in Centereach for 15 years. I'm lucky I don't have to go far for amazing pizza. His specialty pies are absolutely delicious, cooked to a bubbly perfection. (we all love the slices with the big bubble in them too! . the perfect ratio of sauce/cheese/toppings.... TRY THE ZUCCHINI SLICE!!! omg yum.

Just moved to Centereach from Brooklyn and Benny's pizza is the closest think to Brooklyn pizza. He makes you feel right as home as if you were family. I recommend his beautiful dishes to anyone. Thanks Benny see you real soon. -TONY