Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Castleton

Eric at the front counter is awesome and genuine and makes everyone who comes in feel welcome. He's like everybody's favorite cousin : Consistently great food. Our favorites are the cheese/steak sandwiches and the Capistrami. Surprisingly the traditional cheesesteak is better than the Wagyu cheesesteak. Didn't care for the Turkey Bobbie. Cookies are a must.

Super good food. Priced right. Staff was nice, cool and helpful

Love Capriotti’s , specially their Roast Beef Sandwiches. We order via Door Dash at least twice a month. My only complaint is the inconsistency of the serving size of Coleslaw. It’s fabulous coleslaw but when we order as a side, we sometimes get the serving size shown on the Door Dash app, but often (like tonight), we got just a very small serving. Would love to know why this happens?? See photos.

Great, wait…the BEST hot sandwich on northside of Indy

I asked for an earlier pick up then what the restaurant received. When I got there they jumped right on the order. I was entertaining five people coming over to watch football and none of them had tried this restaurant before. Capriotti's now has five more customers! This place rocks! Everybody said this was the best sandwich with the freshest ingredients and they were all impressed!