Old Captiva House - Feedback

The four of us each had a delicious meal excellent service from our server, paige.

First exit there after the storm was cleaned very well. the menu was limited, but had good choices. the waiter has forgotten to mention the particulars that we...

We had a wonderful meal and our server and the staff were great. so glad that this place continues to work through such a challenging time. paige was our server...

I had four meal times there, indeed; two breakfasts and two dinners. eating at all meals was absolutely great and the service was excellent, three times from fo...

Had to wait 1/2hr even though we had a reservation. We go here often and it is always quite good. Think they were overbooked

Upon arrival, we were greeted warmly and seated at a clean table by the window. The service was prompt and knowledgeable. While the menu isn’t specifically labe...

We enjoyed a pleasant, albeit pricey, dinner at Old Captiva House. I started with a tasty Caesar salad topped with plenty of Parmesan cheese, and the house gard...

The food and service were excellent. Just make sure to inquire about the price of the special beforehand—we were shocked when we saw our bill!

Love love love. The Cioppino is my go to here, and we go on multiple nights when we stay at Tween. Service is attentive and welcoming. We've also eaten breakfas...

Best breakfast in the area. Tried bagel, steak and eggs together with pancakes. Awesome place with great service

We would have given this restaurant a much higher rating if it were not for the Twin Lobster Tails that cost $62. They were overcooked, dry and tasteless. The b...

Great as usual. Came for our anniversary and had a fantastic dinner. Lobster risotto was perfect. I had the fish special which was very good and my wife has the...

Greeted warmly by host. Lovely decor. Server, Tony, was gracious and took the time to answer our questions. Great service. Food was delicious and plentiful. Wil...

The whole experience was wonderful. The food was superb, the service excellent and the setting old style Florida charm.

The food was delicious. Possibly top 5 of any meal I've ever had. Appetizers entres were perfect. The service was good but not great. The sunset view was outsta...

I had the Fisherman’s stew which was the best seafood dish of my life. The broth was genuinely addictive. Wine was great too. Incredibly beautiful setting, espe...

Fantastic meal, all four entrees. Highly recommend the Cioppino! Nice ambiance, good service and not too loud.

Colossal shrimp. High end entrees and sides. The carrot rum cake is phenomenal. Appropriate dress is cabana shirts and sun dresses.

Incredible meal and atmosphere. Servers are knowledgeable and attentive. You MUST order the Cioppino. You could live on the broth. Plan around sunset and take l...

Absolutely lovely restaurant! We came here twice during our stay in Captiva and had a great experience both times. The food is excellent, the setting is peacefu...