Underhill Cafe &grill - Brooklyn

Amazing food, service and value. Always consistent and that is key to creating and sustaining a great restaurant and experience for customers.

First time here, and we had an excellent experience. Everything was fresh, flavorful and well enjoyed. The service was impeccable. We will return, and I highly recommend !!

I made a reservation for Underhill Cafe a week in advance BUT, the same day of my reservation, they texted me to tell me that they didn 't have space for me, that they had left the OpenTable app open accidentally, and that I could walk in, but they couldn 't promise anything. I wish they had told me this at any point during the entire week beforehand OR had made even a cursory attempt to accommodate my party of 4. Anything!

After reading excellent reviews on yelp, was very disappointed with overall experience. Food was meh, service was rushed. Would never go back

Absolutely loved it. Fantastic food, great friendly service. Family owned. Loved it.