Andolini's Pizzeria - Broken Arrow

I've ordered from this Andolini's location many times. When they get it right, the food is fantastic, but when they get it wrong it's usually a miserable failure. That's why there are so many mixed reviews here. Last night takes the cake for me. I spent $120 on apps, pizza, and pasta, ordered online via their website and fulfilled by Doordash. Food was at my door 1 hour 10 minutes later which I thought was pretty good for a Saturday night. The pizza was wonderful. The stromboli was a little soggy but still good. The caprese antipasto was a joke. The tomato slices were ENDS you know, the part that's hard to chew and belongs in the garbage and also extremely thinly sliced, barely the width of a fork tine. I don't know how they can possibly think that's acceptable. Also, if there was balsamic glaze on it I couldn't see or taste it. I love this appetizer and it never used to be like this, but it seems like sometime last year they started having problems making it correctly from using tomato ends to missing olives, thin slices of mozzarella, no balsamic, etc. Whenever there's been an issue and I complained, they made it right, but who wants to do that all the time? You know what I really want? For my food to be right the first time. EDIT: After communicating with Mike, the owner, I wanted to add this update to my review. Not only did he make things right with my recent order, he went above and beyond in addressing my concerns about past orders. He cares deeply about his restaurant and is committed to providing customers with a great dining experience, so while mistakes and miscommunications can happen (we're all human, after all) I'm confident I will always be taken care of at Andolini's.

The diavolo is by far the best pizza I have ever had. The diavolo is specially cooked in handmade oven at 900°, turned multiple times for baked perfection. Additionally, Bryan was our server at the bar and he really truly takes care of every customer and experience. Keep up the amazing service! [I was not paid for this comment, I just really like quality pizza and service].

I love Andolini's! My son got me gift certificates for Christmas. Great gift! Pizza Lovers USA

Bought lunch for my crew today. One pizza fed 4 of us with half of it left over. I’m not new to Andolini’s, it’s my favorite place for pizza, but this was one of my favorite experiences. The staff at lunch time today (around 12:45) was SO friendly. Specifically the host and there was a tall server with glasses and his hair up in a bun. Both were very upbeat and energetic, friendly and helpful. Great to see, made me want to go back ASAP.

The service was quick and friendly....we ordered the 30in pizza as we had a coupon for free pizza...so we went whole hog lol. Will Def be going back for more of their garlic knots!!