Jimmy's Pizza Pasta - Branchville

Got a cheese pie yesterday and couldn’t stop eating it! Sooo good!! Best pizza!

Food is good but the customer service is ****. I had the delivery guy tell me I was lucky that he delivered to my house cause it's too far and outside his mile radius. Um, you dont check that before you ok to deliver to someone? They have been delivering to my house for over a year!!! I called and complained and was told they will only deliver during the week cause my house is too far..I have an idea, get a new delivery guy that's not so arrogant and rude and you might not lose customers. I'll find someone else. Thanks!!

I really liked the pizza. Lots of cheese. Not skimpy. Good sauce. Crust was crisp but not tough. Slices were not like yestrday's leftovers. Tasty. Mushrooms were fresh, not canned. Good stuff. Owner is young and super friendly.

I stopped into Jimmy's on the way to Bethel, NY. Despite the hole-in-the-wall exterior, Jimmy's has a familiar, old-school interior. The staff was friendly and the service was very quick. I went with two plain slices and they were fantastic! The slices had an excellent sauce and a great fluffy crust. The cheese was deliciously salty and buttery and the base was perfectly crisp. I'm definitely a fan and will happily return!

New ownership maybe.. not sure.. but often times the phone is off the hook.. last week took 1 hour-to get through and deliveries times of up to 2 hours..something changed.. Not the same Jimmies I will pick up or order from AG from now on..