Nicoletta Pizzeria - BERNARDSVILLE

The pizza here is absolutely amazing and delicious. The ingredients and pizza are always fresh. The only thing I would change about their pizza is the size. Their slices are pretty small and they are charging what other pizza places charge. If they made bigger slices I guarantee they would get more business.

It's good pizza but the prices are insane. In no way is the slice worth 4 dollars. It's really good but 4 dollars for a slice it should be maybe cut into 1/4 . That's 32 dollars off one pie. That's way overpriced. I would come back every day if they cut the price by 1/3 or made the slices 1/4 or at least 1/6 but I can't justify paying that much for a pie and then being asked to tip at the register for a slice to go. That's wild to me.

Top notch staff. Super cheerful girl taking orders for take out and greeting you at the counter. Delivery person was so friendly. Classico pizza, though small is amazing. Easily best pizza around and this is coming from a Hoboken native. The tomato sauce is so fresh. Bravo!

Had a slice of their Italian Buffalo chicken pizza and their parmigiana sandwich. All the chicken cutlets were some how under cooked and nuked in a microwave. There was so much cheese on the sandwich that it was kinda gross and made it hard to eat because you’re pulling 10 feet of cheese with each bite. Sandwich was also really soggy and greasy considering I ate it in 5 minutes of receiving it. And on top of all that almost $3 for a basic can of coke. Would not recommend was barely able to finish a 1/4 of the sandwich and about half of the very small slice. Will not be going back.

I got a pepperoni pizza for the first time. I got home and tried to chew the pizza. The crust was so hard I couldn’t chew the crust. My Great Dane had a hard time chewing as well. I have never had worst pizza. It looked great. But the crust was like eating a shoe.