Rolling Pin Bakery - Bay Shore

I'll always be so grateful for this bakery. My son was on an iodine-free diet for two weeks. This bakery makes Jod free bread that makes my life so much easier. I can't thank them enough. They also make large gluten-free products and delicious pastries. Thank you. Nancy M.

A great Bakery for all your needs. Nothing there I don't like. I even had the make my Wedding cake a couple of years ago. We gave David a picture and they recreated it perfectly. A

I recently ordered desserts from Rolling Pin for my sister's baby shower, and they were absolutely fantastic! The theme was nautical, and the desserts perfectly matched: there were cakes adorned with a beautiful boat design, delightful living cupcakes, and adorable seafood-themed cookies. David, the talented chef, was incredibly accommodating throughout the process. We coordinated everything via email, which made it so convenient. I highly recommend checking out their Instagram to see how amazing and delicious everything turned out. I will definitely be using Rolling Pin again in the future and recommending them to family and friends. The desserts were not only beautiful but also very affordable! They truly made the baby shower a memorable occasion. Thank you, David and Rolling Pin!

I tried some of their offerings and was impressed. The staff was friendly, patient, and helpful as I selected my items. The small lemon tarts and cherry pastries were delicious and reasonably priced. The location is beautiful, with comfortable chairs by the front window and cozy tables for enjoying a meal.

The Rolling Pin Bakery made our wedding cake, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. I communicated with them through phone, email, and in person, and all interactions were excellent. We even got to do a cake tasting from the comfort of our own home, which made the whole process much more relaxed than having to make a decision on-site. The design selection was straightforward and easy, with plenty of lovely options to choose from and creative ways to customize, like using ribbon as accents. The cake itself was absolutely delicious!