Anderson's Frozen Custard - Amherst

Staff are always friendly and their ice cream and custard are consistently Delicious. Enjoy!!

Our first time here. The curly fries were great, the grilled chicken sandwiches we pretty cold but had great flavor and the restaurant was very clean. It was great to have outdoor seating so we could eat with our dogs.

We stop in here when we visit family in the Buffalo area. Everything I’ve had here has been very good. This store well staffed and are very good.

The best ever! Best custard, best beef on wick, just everything! I could have their vanilla custard for every meal. I hope it never closes.

A WNY staple for almost 80 years! Mr Mrs. Carl Greta Anderson, opened the first Anderson’s Frozen Custard in the Bronx, NY. They say that missing family they returned to Buffalo, to open their second custard stand on Kenmore Avenue in 1947. From there they expanded to other locations, such as Tonawanda (pictured in the attached pics), Amherst, Williamsville, Lancaster...The Amherst location lacks some of the initial charm of some of the older locations but is clean, updated and comfortable. There is a drive thru window and outdoor seating when the weather permits. You order at the front counter and they call your name when your food is ready for pick up. This is not a 5 star roast beef, but it's considerably better than an Arby's etc., as this is 100% natural beef (so 4 of 5 stars for me). Moist and delicious every time with Kaiser or the traditional kimmelwick roll options (horseradish available too). My last trip it tasted great, but was cooked a little more than I like (med rare med). Their pickles are pretty amazing too.Curly fries (good not great), salads, soup, chicken and many other options available. Ice cream cones (hard and soft serve)and even delicious ice cream cakes (my favorite) are available to go. Great for parties etc. Fountain drinks (you fill refill) are available with Pepsi and lesser known but unique flavor options including loganberry.If you're hungry and in the area of one of these, stop in!