Fini Pizza Amagansett

We were biking through Amagansett and decided to stop here for a slice since they had outside seating. You don’t walk into the pizzeria but go up to the window and order from the menu. I usually like to see the slices before I order, you can tell right away if it will be good or not. We just opted for the regular slices and a grandma to play it safe. The sauce on the Grandma slice was just weird and it looked like maybe parmesan cheese was sprinkled on top but it didn’t taste like it. As for the regular, nothing special about the sauce or the crust. I am sure there are better places to try.

That lady on the picture charged me 14 dollars for two slices of pizza with pepperoni!!! Taking advantage of people! NOT GOING BACK!

Just a great restaurant that provides fresh great food that’s not overpriced. It’s right in town and parking on street is always available.

Friendly staff and enjoyable food. Normally get a few slices every few weeks there, but last night decided to get a pie to go. We enjoyed it and it was nice to not have to cook for a change. Closest pizzaria to the city out here that I've found so far.

Great place to eat and has good food and friendly staff.