New Sheffield Cafe - Aliquippa

I ordered a chicken tender salad for dinner tonight. I was very disappointed with the portion size - only 3 olives, 8 pieces of cheese, and chicken that seemed more suitable for a child.

I discovered this restaurant on DoorDash and decided to try it out. The food arrived quickly and was delicious for delivery. It was also well packaged. The portions were huge. I ordered...

I have been dining at the New Sheffield Cafe my entire life! It has relocated to a new spot on Brodhead Road. I have probably only visited three or four...

The first time for early dinner. We had the Bret's Special and Gyro. Service overall was great. The salad was not great. The beer was cold, but no frost cups. According to my guest, the Gyro was very good. My Bret's special had three over boiled meat steak, chicken and shrimp. The rice pilaf was excellent. The bread was also excellent. The Pommes were very good. Overall, the meal was good, but not great. I'd go back to try more on the menu. The menu is very diverse.

Great food and generous portions. that has been a home city lover of my family for years. beautiful, casual environment with bar and dining room, very friendly staff and good beer selection. everything on the menu is great, but I love their burgers, gyros and steaksalates best!