Stars Cafe - Shelter Island Heights

I don't get all these bad reviews. It is a small business to make with many orders. It never di...

Great menu, but we could hardly find the turkey on the thanksgiving sandwich! Or the goat chees...

Sweet neighbourhood place. Delicious Mexican breakfast choices. I had the chilaquiles, very goo...

I've been here since 2021 and I have to say that it's the worst experience I had in a café... T...

This is a hidden gem. Fantastic local atmosphere with a wide selection and THE BEST coffee I've...