Amelio's Italian Pizza Shop - Sidney

One star because zero wasn’t an option!They have roaches and gnats!The gnats are in their wine that they do not properly close!The roach came out of a pizza box! Never again!

1st visit was about 6 months after they opened. We waited to give them a try and had hoped they worked out all of the new resturant kinks . We ordered a pizza and it came out in a timely manner. Disppointing from that point forward on how bad the pizza was over half was undercooked doughy and vegetables very crisp. Very disappointed!Took me several attempts to convince my husband to go back. Finally last week he agreed to go and give them a second chance. We ordered 2 pizzas a basic pepperoni and deluxe style. They were not busy, 1 other table and maybe 3 people sitting at the bar. Floor was very dirty and the table close to ushad dirty dishes that sat there the entire time. Service was poor, waited almost 40 minutes for our pizzas. Pizza was cooked this time, but not even warm and very dry! Could be a cute place but owner needs a lot of help with managing a resturant.

Tried the a few months ago, place was busy and service was not good. Understood from the busy night and understaffing. Tried again tonight. Ordered takeout. Pizza, garlic knots, and salad. Was told 30 minutes. Food didn’t come out until 1:10 minutes after I ordered. Two different waitstaff told me it was almost ready during my 45 minute in house wait. Dine in was not busy. Gave me the food, and I had to remind them I didn’t pay. Took 15% off the bill for more than doubling my wait. Sad, because we enjoy the pizza and salad but do not think we will be back.

First time visiting this place, arrived at 5:45 on December 1. Placed order, got appetizer after a while, ordered pizza and salad. Finally got salad. Waited till about 7:15 with no pizza while others around our table who came in after us got their pizza and were about finished. Finally we just paid for the food we did get and left. They actually asked if we wanted the pizza in a box. Waitress never came around to explain what was going on. Not a good experience to say the least.

WOW!!!!! Came in a little on the late side with an appetite hoping to get a bite. They went out of their way to fulfill our request and treated us like locals. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!!!