Sea Star Cafe And - SANIBEL

What a terrible waste of a nice space. It was empty, so all we did was order 2 drinks. They didn't even get that right. They were awful. Someone take this place over and make it an awesome restaurant for the Island!

We came in here at 8pm on a Saturday and were the only people in the place. Drinks were fine but nothing special. We won't be back. 326/365

When every other restaurant had an hour wait, we came here as it was in our hotel! Even though they were short-staffed, the waitress was very accommodating and nice! I had the shrimp scampi and my dad had the ribs, and they were both great! Ignore the bad reviews and stop here one night of your stay!

Food was good. Had Mahi Mahi and Grouper. Both were overseasoned a bit, and the Mahi Mahi was overcooked. Still good! Tasty and fresh. Key lime pie was lovely. Downside: place is insanely overpriced. With a 10% discount we were still over $60 for two people sitting with fake flowers in a tiki bar kinda atmosphere.

We were staying at the Sanibel Inn (June 2013) and wanted a small lunch without having to go far. Located near the Sanibel Inn office, the Sea Star was a obvious choice. We were eating light and simply had the crab bisque. It was excellent. The cafe appeared to have recently built and it looked elegent with a high open ceiling. our waitress was very nice and she provided us with fast, friendly service. Next time here, we will try the dinner menu.