New York Pizza Company

We stopped here on the way to st. augustine. started with a super fresh and delicious caesar salad. we ordered a half/half pizza with my man who got pine on his half. our waitress has accidentally placed the order with ananas on the entire pizza. they have another whole pizza with my half, sans ananas, free. we were in order with the pineapple on the whole pizza, but the owner was on the other pizza. the garlic knots were to die, pizza was fantastic and the service and the hospitality was stellar. many thanks for a wonderful meal for the first night of our honeymoon!

Love this place! the pizza is fantastic and the garlic knots are fantastic! but they have interesting hours, so we had to check first whether they were open. if they have rationalized their ordering process and they can be ordered and placed, they would not have to have wait personnel. excellent eating!

This is our way to pizza place, and we have been customers since its opening. during lunch we can get discs or we can take the whole family to dinner. since the pandemic we started the execution. we think new york pizza is the best! also love the garlic knots!

Very good and large salate with grilled chicken. Garlic butter sauce was delicious. the big meatballs are some of the best of all time. cheyenne has a good work with the table service. highly recommended.

Sad to admit I was disappointed. Large pizza was size of a typical medium pizza. Crust was thin but cheese and toppings were lacking. Had high hopes as I was looking for a new go-to pizza shop near our new home. Second issue was cost. Paid over $45 for two pizzas that were undersized and did not meet expectations. Need to explore all options in a new area. Lesson learned.