Creamery Pizza & Ice Cream - Rushford

Service was not the best, And very slow. Waitress was nice but needs more training!! Kept forgetting things. Had to ask twice for things. Had to.wait at least 10 min for silverware after we had our meal.

Very disappointing! We got a 20? pizza for takeout. There was only enough toppings to cover a 14? pizza. There were areas on the pizza with literally NO cheese on them. Very skimpy on the sauce, mushrooms, and other toppings. Not going back!!

Stopped here because there isn't much in this neck of the woods... glad I stopped. Had a specialty tap beer that was good. For dinner I ordered the 14 Creamery Special pizza. I like a thin crust with extra cheese, and that is exactly what I got. The onlydownside is the service was slow. Not sure if that is because they were understaffed for the evening or if that is a norm. Itdidn't help that my waitress had to man the ice cream counter too. Nice assortment of ice cream flavors but I was stuffed sopassed on dessert.

Service was excellent, prices fair, and ice cream superb. BUT my patty melt came topped with raw onions rather than caramelized, and the hamburger was cooked to leather. The fries were hot but undercooked and limp. Truly awful. My friend had fried fish withfries. The fish was overcooked and the fries even limper than mine. We both left 95% of the fries on our plates. We agreed thatwhile the food was awful, the ice cream was the best. I had the Zanzibar dark chocolate, and my friend had the maple nut. Thepizza we saw delivered to other customers looked awesome. If you?re not hungry for pizza, stick with the ice cream.

John and Gina are great! And so is their pizza. Had one today and will definitely be back and pass the word on to others. You also have a great staff. Keep up the great work.