Gilbey's Seafood and Steak

The food at this restaurant was amazing! I highly recommend trying the steak tacos if you enjoy spicy food. Additionally, the waitress was extremely friendly and helpful without being overbearing.

My wife really enjoyed the Chicken Piccata and I ordered the 12oz NY strip cooked medium well. The steak was tasty but it arrived cold, barely lukewarm. Despite that, we found the meal to be decent overall.

This was our third time in 4 years at Gilbey’s celebrating vacation my birthday. It was incredibly disappointing. The wait staff was not up to the standard set by previous experience. Our food order was wrong not up to the flavor quality of the past. I ordered a steak (medium) with a baked potato. I was served a very very well done steak mashed potatoes. The manager was kind enough to have another steak cooked for me but it came out almost raw. She noticed as soon as I cut into it immediately took it back to the kitchen. It came back out cooked correctly but covered in such a large quantity of spices that I couldn’t taste the flavor of the steak. The baked potato I received was the best part of the meal. I don’t usually complain about food if the service is really good nor do I complain about service if the food is good. Unfortunately both were terrible so here we are. We weren’t offered any discount on the bill which is fine, I only add that detail for frame of reference. We won’t be returning to Gilbey’s again on future visits to Orange Beach.

I could cut the filet with a fork. Great food and our server, Maria, was great. Everyone was very friendly. We will definitely be back!

We have loved Gilbey’s for years so we took a group of 7 Friday night. First the reservation I made on Open Table was challenged by host and we were only seated when I showed confirmation on my phone. Then manager then came over and told us we had been seated at the wrong table! The service was horrible. Waiter was rude and inattentive and his hands did not appear clean. . Fish was fine but NY Strip was tough. Restaurant was not crowded but took 50 minutes to get food. Very disappointed and embarrassed to have guests.