Stella's Pizzeria - Newburgh

I got a Margherita pie here last night with pepperoni and mushrooms. Around 9:30. Probably one of the last pizzas they made on their way out the door. I'm impressed! It was one of the best pies I've had in a very long time and I'm happy that the quality didn't suffer because somebody was trying to go home! Thank you guys for your service! I will order again!

Had the pleasure of visiting my favorite hometown pizza that is currently under new management. The pizza is STILL amazing and I wish the new owners luck in maintaining this important staple of Newburgh.

Gee Never expected this! Culinary Chef and New Owner. I had the Chicken Parm Dish. Fresh Generous cut of Chicken. Cooked to perfection. Oh and the fettuccine? Chef layered it under the chicken, It was so full of flavor, great idea.Yummy it was amazing. Keep up the good work chef Mike !

Amazing! Food and service were great! I wasn’t surprised to learn that there’s a real, culinary trained chef behind it. I first went with my son and then returned with my sister and they both loved it — the pizza was delicious, the salmon salad, the meatballs too! And my son loved the chicken sandwich. No matter what you choose, you won’t be disappointed! Thanks Chef Mike for such great food. I’ll be back soon.

Went for dinner today with my family and i must say the BEST food we ever had. Everything was made to perfection. The portions were huge and the prices were amazing. Will definitely be back. The owner is a real chef the food speaks for itself!! Amazing Amazing!!