Caffe Gelato - Newark

First time dining at Caffe Gelato. We arrived at 4:00 for dinner. Only one other table was seated (from our seated perspective). Our waitress was charming and the atmosphere lovely. Our appetizer arrived quickly and was perfectly delicious. Then nothing. We waited another 45 minutes but were not served our dinner. Our waitress twice told us, a few more minutes, but the food never came. We requested our check, paid, apologized to our server (it 's hard when you

Visited Cafe Gelato for our 4 year wedding anniversary and everything was absolutely wonderful. Atmosphere was quiet and low-key, wait staff was very friendly and kind, and food was absolutely delicious. By luck, our dinner landed on a Tuesday, which was 1/2 bottle of wine night. We enjoyed a fantastic rose, crab pasta, rack of lamb, and quiet honestly the best desert I've had in years. Highly recommend the Raspberry Torte ?? Will definitely be back for brunch one day

I love this place. They were very friendly. The food and Gelato were excellent. I love the way the restaurant was decorated and there are many private dining areas.

Place looks very nice inside.. First time here... got the classico pizza from their Wood fire oven.. its great.. good amount of cheese along with nice, soft and crispy crust... fantastic place... they also service cocktails and other beverages along with ice cream..

We were disappointed at first. Service was less than stellar (wrong food served to one of us and wrong price on the check when we got it). However, the owner of the restaurant came to our table to apologize and explain. The situation was handled extremely well and professionally. Food was excellent. We ordered a pizza and a pasta dish. We will definitely be back, because of the quality of the food, as well as the kindness of the owner. Thank you, Ryan German!