Captain Obadiah's Seafood Market

We received a $250.00 gift card that was purchased in September 2022. I attempted to use it in May 2023. The manager said it was under new ownership and would not honor my $250.00 gift card. The new ownership also owns Yesterday's and the Deauville Inn. After several emails to all restaurants over the summer, I finally got a call from a Chuck last week who said he was 3rd in command. I provided my gift card number and after a 10 minute discussion he said they would not honor the $250.00 gift card. My family has been a frequent guest at all the places since 1999 as we own a property in OCNJ since then. We will be taking our business elsewhere moving forward. I really feel this is a very poor business decision for a guest that has spent thousands of dollars at these restaurants.

Went for the first time last night. Food was good. Not great....good. loved the outside patio. Now I know prices have gone up for everything but, this place was ridiculously expensive for what you got. I don't mind paying a lot but that was not worth what it cost.

Perfect family friendly spot with fresh delicious seafood and great helpful service. Went for lunch after we visited Misty Meadows Farm. The crab cake sandwiches and grilled mahi tacos were a hit. Also very accommodating to the gluten free member in our group.

Sooo good. Most of our party got the lobster rolls and they were very pleased. I got the tacos, which were fantastic. Service was very friendly, and the atmosphere is great. The outdoor seating is beautiful, even with a small amount of road noise from the highway.

Cool people, love the place but the flounder was all bread and the crab cake sandwiches were average twice in a row. I can't recommend spending hard earned money on it.