Binnekill Square - Feedback

Non-existent service. We made a reservation for 7:30. Forty-five minutes later no one had even spoken to us, much less taken a drink or food order. There was no...

Everything was great Service: Dine in Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Schnitzel

The waitress incorrectly informed us that the chile was mildly spicy but it was the spiciest chili that we ever tasted! The waitress also kept pressing the chil...

The service was warm and professional. The outdoor seatings were great, especially for warm summer weather and the view of the river was great. The town was pre...

We had a good experience at the bar, bartender was kind and interested. We had the wings and chicken soup, both very tasty. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner P...

Visiting from nyc. The food was solid. Everything was good. Hood steak and fries, good salad, and hood mussels. The service was great and very accommodating. Th...

I’ll start with the decor inside, on the water, outdoor eating and overall ambience was pretty great. Beautiful place. The server was very attentive and obvious...

Great food, Loraine our server was lovely, and great view over the creek. Could use a few more vegetarian options.

Food was very good, however the staff was noticeably biased towards the regular customers that frequent this establishment. Our wait staff was not very accommod...

The food was amazing. Service was good. Our waitress was so charming. I was very impressed!

Nicole rocks her daughter is also amazing with a tour ACL. Fine young ladies. The food is great. Think about it. I'm sorry I'm terrible with my name, but I hope...

We sat at a table in the bar and it was karaoke night. Had a great time ordered food that was amazing. Our server was excellent. Can't wait to visit again.

We stopped working with Dat for lunch on Saturday weekends. We sat quickly on the terrace overlooking the water. The waitress explained that they had opened a l...

What's going on, guys? We've been coming to Binnekill since the opening. Yesterday evening was one of the worst culinary experiences we had. We waited 20 minute...

Food was very good, made with fresh products. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The cocktails could have been better. The restrooms weren't very clean.

Let me balance out these outrageous ratings real quick... 1. Food? DELICIOUS. 2. Service? INCREDIBLE. 3. Ambience? UNIQUE. This restaurant is severely understaf...

Some of the worst service I 've ever received. Upon arrival we were yelled at by the hostess for booking on OpenTable because apparently they don 't give you th...

Came here with my husband on a trip to the catskills. The food was OK (his burger was better than my pasta) but the waiters were odd and not trained well (we tr...

Well this was my fiance and I's first restaurant stop for her birthday vacation and let me tell you, this place is amazing! We split the Crispy Pork belly buns...

Omg my burger from here was so amazing. While at my mom's I was like let's go check out this place and was just so happy I did. I've been coming up to around th...

I got to enjoy a wonderful dinner with my partner and our dog! They were very accommodating with making sure we felt welcome with our pooch. The drinks were gre...

Great find! We came for Sunday dinner and it wasn’t very crowded. It has a great cozy winter atmosphere (fireplace, etc. The food and drink were incredibly good...

Food surpassed expectations, The portions are large but unlike most restaurants where that is the case the food is very good. We ordered Lamb Shank and Chicken...

None of the towns in this area have many restaurants and I noticed that Margaretville basically has two restaurants this tavern and an Italian restaurant. This...

Great evening here...every time we come! Make reservations on weekends. Fresh ingredients make every item fantastic!