Polito's Pizza - La Crosse

First time at Polito’s, staying in La Crosse for the weekend, googled “best pizza in La Crosse”. The good: online ordering, menu looked promising. The bad: parking is hard to find, a medium pizza with tip is $25, pizza was mushy, wet and floppy. It was so undercooked it was inedible. I was nervous when the pickup time said 12 minutes from when we ordered it. I wanted to love it so much. They need to cook the pizzas longer. Maybe Ask them for well done with the spinach feta pie :

Decided to try this place out and got 3 pizza slices. 2 cheese and 1 macaroni cheese. Wasn’t the biggest fan of how they had the pizzas out in open with no covering or warm lighting. She got the slices then heated them back up briefly in the oven. The cheese slices were decent, but wasn’t big fan of Mac pizza. The pizza was also really greasy which was not pleasant.. overall decent place to try but I’d order the pizzas fresh and not by slice unless they just came out oven.

Freaking excellent pizza. Garlic knots were fresh and delicious as well. Friendly service! Quesadilla pizza was just bomb. ? ? I would have gotten a 2nd slice if I wasn’t stuffed. Fantastic price — got combo 3 for much is 2 pizza slices, garlic knots, and 2 drinks for $16. Very reasonable. Bathroom also very spacious and clean! Always a plus in my book.

The people there are very rude and stuck up, the 3 girls working on 06/13/24 around 630pm. We got a combo 3. Forgot our garlic knots then gave us attitude when asking for them. We got the knots they were cold and not cooked. Gave us attitude again about the food. Didn’t have solutions to fix it just got upset. Manager needs to be involved because the workers have no customer service at all. I expect response from the store and to see some sort of action done.

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE! The staff seemed miserable, as if they all hated their jobs. Additionally, the garlic knots were doughy and undercooked, while the pizza was average at best. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone who isn't a drunk college student.